Leading men as a woman in leadership can be a challenge, especially in the church – but sometimes in the workplace too. Surprising in the 21st century but part of life. It is inevitable that some men will find it unusual to be led by a woman and frequently not the men you think it will be . It is also true that some women find leading men more of an issue than they had anticipated.
I have made big mistakes, and had great mentoring. I learnt much of it in the early days of being on staff on Long Island, NY under Mark Kelsey’s leadership. Mark Kelsey and Bill Clemens who was the Assistant Pastor – were so incredibly good at backing me up and pushing me to stand in the authority I had been given – it was a gift from God and I understand not every woman in ministry gets this support.
So a few things I have learnt along the way, and I am sure there will be more to say on this later
1. Treat All People with respect
Every person – male or female – needs respect. When you are leading people – just because you have a position – it does not give you the right to disrespect any person. Guys especially don’t respond well to being shown a lack of respect..
2. Treat All People Like Family
Treat people like family – they are ! In 1Timothy – Paul says “Do not rebuke and older man harshly but exhort him as if her were your father . Treat younger men as brothers, older women as mothers, and younger women as sisters. ” (1Tim 5:1,2) . Great advice that still works for us now. For me this speaks of leading with the kindness and honour you would afford people in your own family. It also speaks of how we carry ourselves in these relationships – loving the people we lead like our own family.
3. Lead!
If you have been given a role of leadership – lead. You rarely hear a man apologising for leading and you often hear a woman doing it. Don’t apologise for have to make the tough calls and give direction – it is part of your role. Men will not follow you if you don’t actually lead – actually no-one will want to follow you. If you don’t lead you may have the role but some-one else on the team will jump into that vacuum you have created and take the reins.
Lead with confidence knowing that God has anointed you for the task. (Note : If you manipulated your way into a role, you won’t have this confidence, so get yourself out of there fast, repent and allow God to elevate you !)
4. Don’t try to be a man
In fact don’t try to be any other woman either – be yourself. People respond to leaders who are true to themselves, working in their own strengths and talents expressed through their personality. You have been given leadership as YOU – why do we then get into positions and try to be some-one else. If God wanted some-one else he would have put some-one else there. If he wanted a man to do that role I am sure he could arrange it- he is the Creator of the Universe. So relax and be yourself. Of course we look to mentors and role models but ultimately we have to express who we were created to be- anything else is exhausting.
That’s enough for now – I know its the tip of the iceberg, but I wanted to start the discussion.
Girls- what can you add to my list? Guys- give us some insight into being led by woman from your perspective.
(The weird photo is from a first year C3 College activity I run where I blind fold all the first years in the Oxford Falls courtyard – up to 90 people – and make them walk to drum beats – they have to be lead – it is so fun and it seemed appropriate! The other one is a grad photo. )
If you like my blog- you can subscribe in the comments section- or in the sidebar, or the bottom of the page on a digital devise – and it comes into your inbox!
Interestingly enough I think the real issue here is not how to lead but rather how to follow(whatever gender you are or your leader is)
There is much discussion on leadership and much profound thought written by many.
But the real challenge for both men and women is “how do you follow? Especially if you think you know better!”( this is the reality when leading leaders… They think they know better!)
The one book that has profoundly influenced my life is by ps Simon McIntyre .. Called “follow the leader”. His writings hold keys that enable all of us to be able to follow successfully . It is a necessary art to master for success both in and out of the kingdom,for ALL genders!
So true- if everyone could follow none of it would be an issue !
Great blog as usual Pam!
I find that if you want to be a good leader you must first be led by someone you find challenging… It nails the pride issue!
I recently had a man come to me and ask to be mentored! It blessed me as he recognized the gift on my life not my gender!
On the other hand I have been “uninvited” to preach at a couple of churches when they found out that “Nic” was a woman not a man! Wiped the dust off and kept moving!
Nic x
Yes Nic at the end of the day it is all a pride issue – when we are challenged by a persons gender, leadership style, personality – we find out whether or not we have died to our pride. Those churches who did not have you have missed out on a big gift in a little woman !